فردوس ميں ايک مکالمہ
English title: A CONVERSATION IN PARADISE
Hatif said to me that in Paradise one day; Sa‘di of Shiraz addressed Hali in this way:
‘O with the pearl of whose poetry’s sky-illuminating light; the falcon became companion of moon and stars’ light!
Relate to me what the story of the Indian Muslim is: Is he lagging at the halt or busy in exertion is?
Is some warmth of dânleft in his veins? The heat of whose call (Azan) was once burning the sky.’
Hali was moved by the talk of the Shaikh. He started weeping and saying, ‘O man of miracles!
When the sky turned over the leaf of time; the call came that respect was possible only with education!
But this has produced wavering in fundamental beliefs; secular benefits were obtained, but din had been undermined.
Goals also become exalted if the din is preserved; the youth’s nature is paralyzed and very low keyed.
Concordance among individuals is kept only with din. Din is the plectrum if national congregation is the musical instrument.
If the foundation of the garden’s wall is shaken; it is clearly the beginning of the garden’s end.
As the water of Zamzam was not available to it; some manner of atheism is appearing in the new progeny.
Do not talk of this in the audience of the Lord of Yathrib; lest Muslims of India consider that this is my back-biting.’
‘Dates cannot be obtained from the weeds we have sown. Brocade cannot be obtained from the wool we have spun.’
ہم نے جو کانٹے بوئے ہیں ان سے کھجور حاصل کرنے کی توقع عبس ہے ، جو اون ہم نے تیار کی اس سے حریر و پرنیاں اور ریشم تیار نہیں ہو سکتا۔
Sources and translator credits
- Original text transcription: Bang-e-Dara — فردوس ميں ايک مکالمہ — Digital transcription file at commit 39d44fc0c2b8ca25769c4b36e6eac4d90cb42b35; the source dataset does not identify the underlying print edition.Verified against this pinned digital transcription file; not checked against a print edition.Source
- Iqbal Demystified source list: Bang-e-Dara — Pinned digital dataset commit 39d44fc0c2b8ca25769c4b36e6eac4d90cb42b35; the underlying print edition is not identified by the dataset.Community dataset list; not reconciled against a print edition.Source
- Reviewed exact Persian line-language classifications for the digital Urdu collectionsSource
- Bang-e-Dara English translation at allama-iqbal.com — A Dialogue in Paradise — Public digital poem page, retrieved 2026-10-05; pinned to allama-iqbal.com commit 82547635bb6b758c45082084b2f152fc453a8056.Translation by Dr M.A.K. Khalil; English Translation by: Dr M.A.K. KhalilSource
- Bang-e-Dara: published Urdu field at allama-iqbal.com — Public poem data pinned to allama-iqbal.com repository commit 82547635bb6b758c45082084b2f152fc453a8056; source path allama-iqbal-com-content/bang-e-dara/3a/57.json.Translation by Not separately identified; The published Urdu field does not separately identify its translator. No English translator credit is reused.Source
